In July my colleagues and I, together with the Great Plains Institute in Minnesota, organized a Cellulosic Summit in Iowa.  We brought together experts in clean transportation (many from California) with experts in sustainable agriculture (many from Iowa) to see for themselves the latest developments in cellulosic biofuel commercialization.

Cellulosic biofuels are a key element of our strategy to help cut projected oil use in half in 20 years, and today we’re at a critical juncture, with the long-awaited commercial production of millions of gallons of cellulosic biofuel beginning this year.

I’ll be thinking about what I saw and learned for months to come, but here are the top five things I learned:

1. Big Refineries Signal Technological Breakthrough. The Poet-DSM and DuPont Pioneer cellulosic biofuels facilities poised to open this year are a big deal for clean transportation and sustainable agriculture. These early facilities, which represent hundreds of millions of dollars of investment, will work through the technology and logistics challenges of producing cellulosic biofuel at commercial scale, and serve as a proving ground for the technology.  Walking through these huge, complex biorefineries is awe-inspiring, and a testament to the innovative spirit and technological know-how being brought to bear to meet our energy challenge.

Jason Barbose, left, and Jeremy Martin of the Union of Concerned Scientists prepare to tour the Poet/DSM Project Liberty facility. (Photograph by Brendan McLaughlin)

Jason Barbose, left, and Jeremy Martin of the Union of Concerned Scientists prepare to tour the Poet/DSM Project Liberty facility. (Photograph by Brendan McLaughlin)

2. Lots of Corn = Lots of Biomass.  It is well known that Iowa grows a lot of corn—more, in fact, than all but three countries. But a harvested corn plant is only about 50 percent corn grain, and the other half is cellulosic biomass (the stalks, leaves and cobs, called stover). While it’s important to leave some stover behind to protect the soil, we can harvest enough to add a billion gallons of ethanol production in Iowa, without using another kernel of corn. Other states throughout the country also produce large amounts of agricultural residues and manure, which can be made into biofuels, renewable electricity and biogas.

Andy Heggenstaller of DuPont Pioneer stands in front of corn stover bales.  (Photograph by Brendan McLaughlin)

Andy Heggenstaller of DuPont Pioneer stands in front of corn stover bales. (Photograph by Brendan McLaughlin)

3. … Yet Lots of Corn = Lots of Problems. 90 percent of Iowa is farmland, and 70 percent of that land is planted with just two crops: corn and soybeans. Common farming methods leave bare soil exposed most of the year to increasingly severe weather. Storms can wash tons of Iowa’s famous black soil into waterways in just a few days, and fertilizer coming off farm fields (and through subsurface drainage) creates major pollution problems both in Iowa and downstream in the Gulf of Mexico.

Photo showing soil erosion after five inches or more of rain fell in one hour across portions of Western Iowa in 2013. (Photograph courtesy USDA/Natural

Photo showing soil erosion after five inches or more of rain fell in one hour across portions of Western Iowa in 2013. (Photograph courtesy USDA/Natural

4. Smart Biofuels Means Smart Farming. The only way to make sustainable biofuels is to practice sustainable farming. Iowa State University and companies like AgSolver are employing complex modeling tools to help farmers make smart economic decisions on their land: where to plant corn, where it makes sense to use part of their corn stover to make ethanol, and where they should plant perennial grasses (highly productive sources of cellulosic biomass) instead or corn. Not only can this make the farmers’ operations more profitable, it can keep pollution out of the water, reduce erosion, and someday soon, produce biomass for cellulosic biofuel.

 

Cereal rye cover crop planted into corn stubble (Photograph courtesy USDA/Natural Resources Conservation Service)

Cereal rye cover crop planted into corn stubble (Photograph courtesy USDA/Natural Resources Conservation Service)

5. Perennial Crops Have a Big Role to Play. For the foreseeable future, Iowa will continue to grow a lot of corn and soybeans, but integrating perennial grasses into the system can provide benefits far in excess of the land they occupy. Scientists from the STRIPS research team (Science-based Trials of Row-crops Integrated with Prairie Strips) have shown that by strategically converting as little as 10 percent of a row-cropped field to perennial prairie—in narrow patches along contours and foot slopes—farmers and landowners can reduce soil erosion and fertilizer runoff by 85-95 percent. As cellulosic biofuel production scales up, there will be a growing market for these clean, sustainable crops.

Professor Matt Helmers from Iowa State University showed us around the STRIP project. (Photograph by Amanda Bilek)

Professor Matt Helmers from Iowa State University showed us around the STRIP project. (Photograph by Amanda Bilek)

To cut oil use and carbon emissions from transportation and make our agricultural system more resilient and sustainable, we need to change the way we produce fuel and the way we farm. Experts in Iowa are hard at work making that happen. Seeing the beginning of large-scale production of corn-stover based cellulosic biofuel is exciting: the technology is working, and sets us up well to begin growing and harvesting perennial crops to feed the growing industry. It’s an important milestone on the road to clean fuels and sustainable agriculture.

Comments

  1. Mark Gebert
    Palo Alto, CA
    September 11, 11:44 am

    Are all of these Cellulosic Ethanol plants convertable to produce other biofuels such as butanol which are compatible with the existing gasoline infrastructure?

  2. Peter Doherty
    USA
    September 2, 10:27 am

    No mention of sustainable, grassland bird populations. Forage and grain production and harvest practices have largely caused the decline of our grassland bird populations. Will the harvest periods of perennial grasses allow grassland birds (and butterflies?) the time and opportunities to nest/reproduce successfully?

  3. Jeremy Martin
    United States
    August 28, 11:49 am

    Thanks Scott and Douglass for your comments. You are right on about using digesters to produce biogas. I actually wrote about this topic recently (see link below). And as to learning about sustainable practices at Purdue, Professor Wally Tyner at Purdue brought to my attention a recent study he did with Dave Muth, who spoke at our Cellulosic Summit, on how markets for corn stover to produce biofuel can help pay the cost of the using cover crops, addressing an economic challenge that has stood in the way of this well know best practice. So learning in this area continues in Indiana as well as Iowa.

    Blog on Biogas: http://blog.ucsusa.org/ice-cream-and-electric-vehicles-rfs-587
    Pudue Study: http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.agsy.2014.06.008

  4. Scott Sinnock
    Woodstock, IL
    August 26, 8:36 pm

    I learned all about these and other “good agricultural” practices at Purdue in the 1970’s. Are we finally ready to listen?

  5. Douglas Lass
    United States
    August 13, 1:38 pm

    Another possible way to produce energy from cellulosic biofuels is to use it in methane digesters. It not only produce methane gas, but also compost that can be spread on the farm as a fertiliser.