U.S. Nuclear Regulators Defer Decision on Vent Filters
The Nuclear Regulatory Commission has delayed a final decision on requiring filters for emergency vents on the 31 U.S. nuclear reactors that are similar in design to those at Japan’s ill-fated Fukushima Daiichi.
NRC staff experts earlier concluded the vents should be outfitted with filters, even though the chance of a failure that would require their use is extremely small. But the NRC commissioners decided Tuesday on a 3-2 vote to defer a final decision on the filters for at least another year for more study and public comment. (See related, “Safety Question on Fukushima Anniversary: Should Plants of the Same Design Have Filtered Vents?“)
The decision is a victory, at least for the time being, for the nuclear power industry, which has agreed to upgrade vents on the reactors, but has resisted the filters. The filters can’t be justified under normal cost-benefit analysis. But in nuclear regulation, there are some safety measures that are not subject to a cost-benefit approach; they are simply deemed necessary. The filter debate centers around the question of whether this is a measure that falls in that category of costly but essential protection. (Related Quiz: “What Do You Know About Nuclear Power?“)
When Fukushima Daiichi lost power in the wake of the March 2011 earthquake and tsunami and the meltdown began, the build-up of hydrogen gas caused an explosion that destroyed the containment buildings and resulted in the release of radiation. (Related: “Japan Reactor Crisis: Satellite Pictures Reveal Damage“)
Filters are required on these reactors in Europe, and have been required since last year in Japan. An upgrade of vents is underway now at U.S. plants, with completion scheduled for the end of 2016. Estimates on additional costs for filtering the vents vary, but the industry uses a figure of $15-20 million each.” (Related: “Photos: Rare Look Inside Fukushima Daiichi“)
The NRC is designed to be a bipartisan regulatory body, with the majority from from whichever party holds the White House. In the vote yesterday, one Democrat joined the Republicans in deciding to defer a decision on the filters pending further study. Following word of the vote, California Democratic Senator Barbara Boxer issued a statement critical of the NRC’s decision.
“The Nuclear Regulatory Commission should never cut corners when it comes to safety, especially after Fukushima,” she said. “We should accept the recommendations of safety experts and not just accept a partial fix.”
Alex Chadwick is the host of the public radio series, BURN: An Energy Journal, from SoundVision productions and American Public Media’s Marketplace, produced with funding from the Alfred P. Sloan Foundation.
Related Topics
Go Further
Animals
- Octopuses have a lot of secrets. Can you guess 8 of them?
- Animals
- Feature
Octopuses have a lot of secrets. Can you guess 8 of them? - This biologist and her rescue dog help protect bears in the AndesThis biologist and her rescue dog help protect bears in the Andes
- An octopus invited this writer into her tank—and her secret worldAn octopus invited this writer into her tank—and her secret world
- Peace-loving bonobos are more aggressive than we thoughtPeace-loving bonobos are more aggressive than we thought
Environment
- Listen to 30 years of climate change transformed into haunting musicListen to 30 years of climate change transformed into haunting music
- This ancient society tried to stop El Niño—with child sacrificeThis ancient society tried to stop El Niño—with child sacrifice
- U.S. plans to clean its drinking water. What does that mean?U.S. plans to clean its drinking water. What does that mean?
- Food systems: supporting the triangle of food security, Video Story
- Paid Content
Food systems: supporting the triangle of food security - Will we ever solve the mystery of the Mima mounds?Will we ever solve the mystery of the Mima mounds?
History & Culture
- Strange clues in a Maya temple reveal a fiery political dramaStrange clues in a Maya temple reveal a fiery political drama
- How technology is revealing secrets in these ancient scrollsHow technology is revealing secrets in these ancient scrolls
- Pilgrimages aren’t just spiritual anymore. They’re a workout.Pilgrimages aren’t just spiritual anymore. They’re a workout.
- This ancient society tried to stop El Niño—with child sacrificeThis ancient society tried to stop El Niño—with child sacrifice
- This ancient cure was just revived in a lab. Does it work?This ancient cure was just revived in a lab. Does it work?
- See how ancient Indigenous artists left their markSee how ancient Indigenous artists left their mark
Science
- The unexpected health benefits of Ozempic and MounjaroThe unexpected health benefits of Ozempic and Mounjaro
- Do you have an inner monologue? Here’s what it reveals about you.Do you have an inner monologue? Here’s what it reveals about you.
- Jupiter’s volcanic moon Io has been erupting for billions of yearsJupiter’s volcanic moon Io has been erupting for billions of years
- This 80-foot-long sea monster was the killer whale of its timeThis 80-foot-long sea monster was the killer whale of its time
- Every 80 years, this star appears in the sky—and it’s almost timeEvery 80 years, this star appears in the sky—and it’s almost time
Travel
- This town is the Alps' first European Capital of CultureThis town is the Alps' first European Capital of Culture
- This royal city lies in the shadow of Kuala LumpurThis royal city lies in the shadow of Kuala Lumpur
- This author tells the story of crypto-trading Mongolian nomadsThis author tells the story of crypto-trading Mongolian nomads