Reports that SolarWorld had formally brought its solar trade fight against China to Europe elicited a fresh round of scorn from critics within the industry this week, but the company said it had not in fact filed a complaint. Yet.

“We have always said that we will ask the European Union to take urgent action against unfair competition from Chinese solar manufacturers,” SolarWorld AG said in a statement emailed to media late Tuesday. “We can confirm that SolarWorld is working together with leading European manufacturers to urge the European Commission to act. We will not reveal any specific dates, however the European industry initiative will communicate its intentions in the coming days.”

SolarWorld’s U.S. unit has already convinced American trade authorities that the Chinese are cheating on solar, and early Tuesday The Wall Street Journal and Financial Times reported the Germany-based company had joined with other European firms in lodging a complaint with the European Commission.

The Financial Times said the complaint centered strictly on dumping, accusing Chinese firms of selling their solar products in Europe at below cost in order to shut down foreign competitors. A similar charge in the U.S. has won a preliminary ruling of duties of around 31 percent on Chinese products, to go along with anti-subsidy duties of around 4 percent.

SolarWorld’s efforts in the U.S. have drawn it some allies, particularly among domestic manufacturers, as you might expect. But installers and others have grown increasingly loud in their denunciation of the company. After the news broke — prematurely, it turned out — that a complaint had been filed in Brussels, the Coalition for Affordable Solar Energy said that “like a crazed agent provocateur, SolarWorld is fueling global solar industry infighting for its own selfish interest.”

CASE is fronted by SunEdison founder Jigar Shah and includes among its members installation heavyweights such as SunrunSungevity and SolarCity, as well as the U.S. units of the Chinese manufacturers Suntech and Trina Solar.

“Today Germany-based SolarWorld has once again demonstrated that it is willing to undermine the world’s solar industry in a desperate effort to avoid competition in the marketplace,” CASE’s statement read. “The entire global solar industry – manufacturers, suppliers, installers and consumers — has benefited from the sharp decline in the price of solar cells, and our industry’s future success is predicated on our ability to continually improve the economics of solar electricity generation. SolarWorld desperately needs that trend to halt to remain competitive. ”

Whether it’s good or bad for the industry, or for consumers, bringing a complaint in Europe would emphasize the global nature of solar’s troubles — something often lost on Americans fixated on the small number of companies who received federal backing and then failed. Excess capacity is an industrywide problem, and China’s ability (or willingness) to sell its products so cheaply has left companies around the globe vulnerable.

Citing data from Eurostat, the Journal said Chinese solar imports had grown tenfold in Europe in the past five years and prices had fallen by half.  Solar World’s revenue in Europe fell 30 percent in 2011.

Under EU trade rules, once a complaint is filed, the European Commission will decide within 45 days whether to open a formal investigation – “something that many analysts believe is likely” with the expected SolarWorld complaint, the Finacial Times reported.

— Pete Danko

This post originally appeared at EarthTechling and was republished with permission.


  1. david lim
    August 1, 2012, 2:02 am

    American and European solar manufacturers backed by subsidies of their government are just sour grapes that they chose the more expensive thin film solar technology that did not fare out well so they blame PRC for their failures, lol…

  2. Echo Liang
    July 30, 2012, 5:42 am

    Xiamen Grace Solar Awarded New Zealand 720KW Roof Photovoltaic Power Plant Project

    New Zealand solar roof PV power plant project construction is being carried out, until now, the land is leveled. This project with 720KW installed capacity applies the roof photovoltaic mountings from Grace Solar.
    Completion of this project with obvious energy saving benefits will improve the living environment and life quality of the surrounding area. Meanwhile, it will be a tourist attraction with high-tech environmental protection theme, which contributes to the further development of tourist industry of New Zealand and create a new economic growth point.
    Grace Solar adjustable PV mountings are the fixed adjustable PV mountings specially for the large-scale PV power plant. It is easy to adjust the angle (ranging from 10 degrees to 60 degrees) and install. This adjustable solar photovoltaic stent is designed according to the demand of the inclination angle of PV station, so that it can absorb the sunlight with maximum efficiency and at least increase 12% green electrical energy output from New Zealand roof PV power station.